top of page

Rate Buydown or Price Cut: Which Helps a DFW Buyer More?

Writer: Janine Alexander
Janine Alexander
14 minutes ago
3 min read

"The seller is offering money toward your rate!"

Sounds amazing, right? Free money. Those two words make me squint a little. I've worked through plenty of price cut vs. buydown decisions, and I'll say it plainly: neither one is automatically the better deal.

So let's put the same seller dollars on the table both ways.

What's a 2-1 buydown, anyway?

It's a temporary discount. The seller puts money in at closing, and your payment is calculated at a rate 2 points lower in year one and 1 point lower in year two. By year three, you're paying the full rate.

Here's the part I really want you to hear: your actual loan rate didn't change. Under Fannie Mae's rules, the lender qualifies you at the full note rate, so a buydown won't help you qualify for more house. It's a discount on the payment, not a new loan.

Same money, two very different results

Quick example. This is an illustration, not a lender quote. Say you buy at $379,000 (about the October DFW median), put 5% down, and get a 30-year fixed at 7.11% (the Freddie Mac average on Nov. 12). Principal and interest only, no taxes or insurance.

  • No concession: about $2,422 a month.

  • 2-1 buydown: about $465 less in year one, about $238 less in year two, then back to $2,422. The seller's bill for that is roughly $8,400.

  • Same $8,400 as a price cut: your payment drops about $54 a month. Not exciting. But it lasts as long as the loan does, and you borrow a little less from day one.

Fifty-four dollars doesn't sound like much, does it? It would take about 13 years of those savings to match what the buydown hands you in the first two. Then again, only one of these is still working for you in year five.

So which one do I ask for?

Start with your plans, not the seller's flyer.

Selling or refinancing in a few years? The buydown front-loads the relief. But a refinance is never guaranteed, and rates may not budge, so be sure you're comfortable with the full payment.

Staying put for the long haul? Look hard at the price cut. And ask your lender to price a permanent buydown with points too.

One more thing: a seller credit doesn't change the contract price. A price cut does, which can matter if you're worried about the appraisal.

Seller money has a ceiling

On a conventional loan, the cap depends on your down payment. With less than 10% down, it's 3% of the price, which is $11,370 in our example. That covers the $8,400 buydown, as long as nothing else is using up that allowance. FHA and VA have their own caps, so your lender needs to confirm the numbers for your loan.

Ask why they're offering it

On the listing side, I have a process for homes that are sitting. Before I'll talk about cutting the price or offering "free money," I want to know the home is showing its full value. A concession should fix a problem, not distract from one. (If you're a seller with a stale listing, call me. I'm happy to take a look. No, I'm not putting the whole recipe in a blog post. 😉)

I bring that same thinking to buyers. When a seller advertises a buydown, I ask why, and whether the price makes sense for the house and its competition.

Quick questions

Does a 2-1 buydown help me qualify for a bigger loan?

No. Lenders qualify you at the full rate.

Is a price cut always better?

Nope. A price cut keeps paying off over time. A buydown gives you a lot more breathing room early. Your timeline decides.

What should I do before choosing?

Get both scenarios from your lender in writing. Compare the payment you'll eventually owe, not just the shiny first-year number.

Looking at a home in Carrollton, Plano, or anywhere around DFW? I'm happy to help you weigh the house and the offer separately. Sometimes the answer is payment, sometimes it's price, and sometimes it's to keep looking.

No pressure. Just good info so you can make a decision you understand.

— Janine

Sources

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page