top of page

Price Your DFW Home for the Payment, Not Just the Comps

Writer: Janine Alexander
Janine Alexander
7 hours ago
3 min read

Still hanging on to what your neighbor sold for in 2022?

I get it.

But your buyer isn't shopping with a 2022 mortgage payment. They're shopping with today's. And with the average 30-year mortgage rate at 7.28% this week, that distinction is doing some heavy lifting.

Your buyer cares about a different number.

The monthly payment.

Your Buyer Has Already Done the Math

When I'm working with buyers, I want them to get their Loan Estimate (the loan disclosure) from their lender and look at the monthly payment before we ever look at a house.

Because, as I tell them, “people buy based on that - not the pricetag.”

A house can check every box. But pretty countertops won't fix an unaffordable payment.

Now flip that around if you're selling.

Your buyer has already done this. Price like you know it.

Here's an illustration, not a lender quote: October's median DFW sale price was $379,000. With 20% down and a 30-year loan at 7.28%, that's about $2,075 a month in principal and interest.

At the 3.22% rate from early January 2022? The exact same purchase price would have been about $1,315 a month.

That's roughly $760 more every month for the same price tag.

That excludes taxes, insurance, and HOA dues. (Hello, Texas.) Actual payments vary.

I understand why sellers remember 2022 prices. But we have to look at today's buyer.

Comps Matter. So Does the Search Bar.

Comparable sales matter. I'm not tossing data out the window.

But comps tell us what homes have sold for. They don't, by themselves, tell us which buyers can comfortably make today's payment—or whether those buyers will even find your listing.

People search for homes in price brackets. Your asking price determines which searches you appear in and which ones you miss.

Here's the surprise: in our example, dropping the price $10,000 changes principal and interest by only about $55 a month. A $25,000 reduction changes it by about $137 a month.

That's not exactly a dramatic payment rescue.

I'd rather price thoughtfully before listing than chase the market afterward.

The goal isn't to be the cheapest house. It's to make sense to the right buyer.

Same Market. Very Different Results.

In October, I sold a home in Carrollton in two days on market and another in Plano after three days on market. Both were in the $500s. Both were turnkey and beautiful.

Meanwhile, other properties in those same neighborhoods sat for 40-plus days.

Same neighborhoods. Same general market. Very different outcomes.

What makes the difference?

There's always a story to tell and discover.

That's why I don't believe pricing is a magic number you pull from a spreadsheet and call it a day. A home has to make sense as a complete offering to the people most likely to buy it.

And this isn't just theoretical: more than one in four DFW listings had a price cut in October, according to Realtor.com.

Sometimes a reduction is right. But what problem are we solving?

Already Listed and Hearing Crickets?

Please don't assume the only answer is to slash the price or throw “free money” at buyers.

I have an entire process for rehabbing a listing that's lost momentum. And no, I'm not giving away the whole playbook here.

What I will tell you is that I want a home showing its full value before we start talking about giving any of that value away.

Sometimes it's price. Sometimes there's more to the story.

Quick FAQ

Should I price high so I have room to negotiate?

Not automatically. With 4.6 months of supply in DFW in October, an ambitious price can cost you attention and showings before negotiations even begin.

How much does a $10,000 price cut save a buyer?

About $55 a month in principal and interest in the illustration above, assuming 20% down and a 7.28% 30-year rate. Taxes, insurance, and other costs are extra.

Do comps still matter?

Absolutely. They're where the pricing conversation starts. The buyer's payment—and the competition—help us finish it.

Thinking about selling in Carrollton, Plano, or anywhere around DFW? Or already listed and wondering why nobody's biting?

Call me. We'll look through today's buyer's eyes and figure out what makes sense for you. No pressure.

— Janine

Sources

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page